Friday, September 17, 2004
The Logic of Freedom
Finally, for all the media-inspired pessimism, progress continues in Iraq. Despite all the killing, a logic of freedom persists, one that is slowly becoming a way of life for millions and that cannot be derailed by media-savvy murderers. Scheduled elections are on track. A culture of personal liberty is sprouting up, from Internet cafes to secular schools. Kurdistan is emerging as a federated republic. Indeed, Kurdish good will is proof that America wants no one's oil, promotes democracy, and is becoming once again a dependable friend. When the United States has chosen to confront the militias, it has won handily. It can do so again in Fallujah and Najaf should the interim government wish a final victory — and our political leadership at last allows the Marines to eradicate terrorist killers who have turned the city of Fallujah into a murderous sewer.
And, while we are on the subject of Iraq, Wretchard over at Belmont Club continues his analysis of the insurgency and the power vacuum created by the U.S. military success, particularly in the Sunni areas.
Kerry, In His Own Words
UPDATE: Link fixed--sorry about that!
Iraqi Bloggers
Thursday, September 16, 2004
IRAQ Perspective
- Iraq is NOT descending into anarchy; and
- The Insurgency is pretty much bounded by the Sunni Triangle and American casualties have occurred predominantly in that area
Since this is not the overall impression given by the manistream media and Leftist pundits (here and here, for example), it is recommended that you read the entire analysis and look over the data.
What seems to get lost in discussions and rhetoric about Iraq are the following facts:
1) this is a WAR and soldiers die in wars--an inescapable outcome of soldiering and war, although any deaths are clearly regrettable and tragic for the families involved. What is truly remarkable is the LOW LEVEL OF DEATHS AND CASUALTIES for this war, never before seen in ANY major military conflict.
2) that U.S. soldiers are all PROFESSIONAL warriors, meaning they represent an all-volunteer military and are not serving against their will;
3) that, with the continued battles and violence primarily located in one area of Iraq; the remainder is progressing fairly well toward developing democratic institutions (see here and here);
4) that a majority of Iraqis actually ARE grateful for their freedom and view America in a positive light (here, and here and check out all the Iraqi bloggers); and
5) Iraqis themselves are optimistic about their future.
And, while all of the above are true, it is not defeatism to admit that problems are likely to persist for some time, and that reports like this need to be kept in context and factored into overall military and political strategies.
Why is all this important? I believe that Iraq is a key element in a plan to bring democracy and freedom to the Middle East as part of a strategy to decrease terrorism in the next generation. This kind of long-range planning requires long-range perspective and perseverance- neither of which are virtues encouraged by our political system, unfortunately. Yet, the consequences if we do not "terraform" this part of our world and deflect it from its current suicidal /homicidal course are enormous--both for our generation, and the next.
Nauseating
The caption reads: “You can do a lot in one single day; just imagine what can happen in three months.”
From Barcepundit via Little Green Footballs
A TRULY NAUSEATING THING FOR A NEWS ORGANIZATION TO CELEBRATE, DON'T YOU THINK?
UPDATE: The Spanish newspaper has now apologized and retracted the ad campaign.
Wednesday, September 15, 2004
Damage Control
From RealClearPolitics come this apropo cartoon!
Terrorism and the TV News
However, the Pew Charitable Trusts' 2004 report on the state of the U.S. media found a troubling trend: News outlets “disseminate” news from other sources rather than collect it themselves, and the end video product often becomes repetitive, chaotic and incoherent “raw news.” Ultimately, news decisions are surrendered to those who would manipulate it for their own ends.
This has resulted in non-stop images of hostages, street fighting and gun-waving insurgents. With virtually each new kidnapping or slaughter, a video emerges and is dutifully aired. The source of the footage frequently is not identified. The most dangerous television practice, though, is the “personalization” of news reports.
Putting a face on every gory story has turned some terrorists into celebrities, on par with world leaders. Khalid Shaikh Mohammed, the 9/11 mastermind, told interrogators that he was “inspired” by the “instant notoriety” garnered by the planners of the 1993 World Trade Center attacks. He said he wanted to cast himself as a “superterrorist” in this new “theater” of destruction. In essence, television gave him enormous motivation to commit a bigger, more terrible act.
She points out that TV has become a source of "Terrorist Infomercials" and makes several sensible suggestions on how the network news organizations might deal with this situation:
- A refusal to air video or other propaganda from terrorist Web sites or other anonymous terrorist sources, except in the rare circumstances that such information warns viewers of an imminent, credible threat.
- A prohibition against using images that aren't shot by network or other legitimate photographers. That means not using video shot by terrorists or insurgents, because these images are suspect, often staged for propaganda.
- A new practice of prominently labeling all non-network, freelance or bystander video — akin to the photo credit in print journalism — so audiences can judge the source of each image.
- A commitment to require the same sharp scrutiny and relentless challenges to terrorists and insurgents that journalists traditionally give our own government and military officials.
I particularly applaud the 3rd and 4th suggestions. What I find most objectionable about the airing of these terrorist images is that it is almost never put into any context by the news organizations presenting it. The images are simply presented without explanation- except for the "man on the street" interview that only serves to confirm the message that the particular network wanted to get across in the first place. There is virtually no explanation of the important aspects of a real journalistic story: we get the "what", "where" and "when"; but rarely an appreciation of the "why" and a watered down version of the "who" (e.g., "militants", rebels", "insurgents", etc. etc. but no use of the word "terrorist").
Read the entire piece.
Tuesday, September 14, 2004
For Our Children's Children
Here is a summary of the plot:
Nathan is a rich merchant in Jerusalem. An infant girl (Recha) is placed into his custody by a monk. The secret of the child's identity is known only by Nathan, the monk, and Nathan's Christian servant (Daya). Nathan raises her to respect God, but without teaching her the trappings of any religion. While Nathan is away on a business trip, Recha is rescued from death by a German knight who had come to Jerusalem as part of the Crusades. She falls in love with him. Nathan returns and when he tries to thank the knight, he is spurned because the knight disdains friendship with a Jew. But the knight yields to Nathan's pleas and visits Recha, with whom he falls in love.
The servant informs the knight that Recha was born a Christian. Obsessed by a sense of sacred duty he turns to the Christian Patriarch of Jerusalem for advice. He is repelled by the latter's self-righteousness and inhumanity (the character is drawn quite negatively). The knight then visits the Sultan, Saladin. When he denounces Nathan, he is rebuked by the Sultan who tells him not to be a Christian at the expense or injury of Jews or Moslems. Nevertheless, the Sultan pledges to bring the lovers together. But the play ends with the revelations that Recha and the knight are really sister and brother and that their father was tire Sultan's brother.
The owner of the ring had three wonderful, obedient sons he loved with all his heart. Because he could not decide among them, he had identical rings made for all of them before he died. When the sons realize they each have a ring from their father they become angry and take their case to a judge to determine who has the real ring. The judge considers and finally makes his decision:
CBS = Media Joke
GW Bush: "We found WMD in Iraq. All of our critics have been completely discredited"
Media: Can we see them?
GW - No. you'll just have to take my word for it. We have experts to prove their authenticity.
Media: Can we talk to the experts? Can we interview the people who found the weapons?
GW: NO. And the mere fact that you are asking these questions proves that you are partisan rumor mongers. End of story. Case closed.
I wonder if the Left will start referring to Dan Rather as Hitler? Probably not, but consider this: a major media outlet that follows a political agenda; determines what is "best" for its viewers to know; and feels itself above the need to answer questions about its stories, motives and facts, is not much better than the old Soviet propaganda outlets Pravda (meaning "truth") and Izvestia (meaning "news").
And, as with those two Russian media giants - where the joke in Russia was that there was very little "truth" in Pravda; and no "news" in Izvestia - soon that's all CBS will be: a joke.
Monday, September 13, 2004
Hamster Wars!
The battle began at the Democratic National Convention when Alexandra Kerry, candidate John Kerry’s daughter, told what she obviously believed was a touching story of her heroic father. "We were standing on a dock waiting for a boat to take us on a summer trip," she said. "Our golden retriever got tangled in his leash and knocked the hamster cage off the dock. We watched as Licorice, the unlucky hamster, bubbled down to a watery doom. But my dad jumped in, fished the cage from the water, and began to administer CPR."
Now, granted, this is a pathetic image of a man so desperate to please his kids, so eager to protect his reputation as a "man of action," that he would resuscitate a dying hamster. Knowing Kerry, it wouldn’t surprise me to hear that he also grabbed a hamster defibrillator and yelled "CLEAR!" as he energized the tiny paddles on little Licorice’s chest—and then put in for a Purple Heart (for himself, not Licorice).
Read the whole thing--it's pretty funny!
Vietnam Veterans Against Kerry
"Kerry already made his choices....In choosing how to relate and react to the circumstances in which he found himself--in choosing how to relate and react to the Vietnam War--Kerry created his identity and defined himself as a man lacking character, integrity, and moral courage."
Check it out. It will give you some perspective.
The Axis of Evil, Parts II and III
"Our second goal is to prevent regimes that sponsor terror from threatening America or our friends and allies with weapons of mass destruction. Some of these regimes have been pretty quiet since September the 11th. But we know their true nature. North Korea is a regime arming with missiles and weapons of mass destruction, while starving its citizens.
Iran aggressively pursues these weapons and exports terror, while an unelected few repress the Iranian people's hope for freedom.
Iraq continues to flaunt its hostility toward America and to support terror. The Iraqi regime has plotted to develop anthrax, and nerve gas, and nuclear weapons for over a decade. This is a regime that has already used poison gas to murder thousands of its own citizens -- leaving the bodies of mothers huddled over their dead children. This is a regime that agreed to international inspections -- then kicked out the inspectors. This is a regime that has something to hide from the civilized world.
States like these, and their terrorist allies, constitute an axis of evil, arming to threaten the peace of the world. By seeking weapons of mass destruction, these regimes pose a grave and growing danger. They could provide these arms to terrorists, giving them the means to match their hatred. They could attack our allies or attempt to blackmail the United States. In any of these cases, the price of indifference would be catastrophic. " (Emphasis mine)
Remember the outrage around the world by the Left ?(here, here, here , here, here)
The general tone of which was: My God! How dare Bush call these countries evil! How dare he confront dictators who destroy their own people? How dare he suggest that they would do anything....bad! Who does he think he is?"
Fast Forward two years.
IRAN : Getting closer to having a nuclear bomb, which would make it the most powerful country in the Middle East, with the exception of Israel. It has actively worked to destabilize its neighbors; continues to harbor terrorists from Al Qaeda; actively suppresses the freedom of its own people; murders female children under the auspices of "Sharia". America, through President Bush's policies has placed itself squarely on the side of freedom in Iran.
NORTH KOREA: Defiantly touting its own nuclear weapon program; its own people starving, it persists in its pursuit of weapons with which it can threaten and blackmail its neighbors; as well as the U.S. Its recent activities suggest it is ready to actually test a nuclear weapon. The Bush Administration's policy toward North Korea has been consistent and confrontative and is based on the reality of North Korea's behavior, not on wishful thinking. Knowing that it has broken promises and treaties in the past, the Administratin has pursued a policy of multilateral diplomacy, refusing to give North Korea the aid it wants until it changes its nuclear policy.
IRAQ: Because of Bush's doctrine of preemptive action against states that represent a developing threat, Iraq's dictator has been deposed, the Iraqi people have a real chance of developing democracy; and Iraq has become a magnet for the Al Qaeda terrorists who have been unable to attack the homeland again. They are therebecause they want to attack American soldiers. But because they are there, we finally have access to THEM also. I would rather have us deal with them away from the U.S. mainland. And, I believe that the U.S. Military is doing its job--protecting us--splendidly and should be honored for it. 1000 American deaths are tragic, but not anywhere near the number of deaths I believe we might have suffered if we had remained passive. Just note that more than 2800 people died on 9/11 and many thousands were injured. It was not the job of the people who worked in the WTC to protect US citizens--that is the proud job of the volunteers who are our Army, Navy, Marines, and Air Force.
Most importantly, the possibility of a democracy in Iraq, the middle of the Arab World, has shaken things up dramatically. The effects of this bold and decisive military intervention will have important repercussions on the politics of this region for decades to come. Some of the effects may be negative, but the hope (and for the first time there IS hope) is that our action will ultimately result in more freedom, more economic advancement; and more peace in that historically chaotic region.
Personally, I think that President Bush did what needed to be done in his 2002 State of the Union speech: HE CALLED A SPADE A SPADE. And he refocused the discussion onto the regimes that were and are slowly but surely inching their way toward world domination.
What diplomats had been skirting around for decades was distilled into a blunt assessment of reality and the state of the world. If these three regimes could not be called Evil, then Evil has no meaning. I believe this was one of the most brilliant achievements of Bush's first term as President. In addition, the President made a good start in dealing with these three Powers. 33% of the axis is now not a threat to the homeland. If we learned anything from the appeasement and passivity that existed prior to WWII, it is that we cannot wait for Evil to consolidate and expand its power. Especially when they now have weapons that could destroy millions in one demonstration of egomaniacal bluster or religious fanaticism. Hitler was the prototype of of totalitarian rulers like Kim Jung Il and the Mullahs of Iran and yes, Saddam Hussein. Those who try to pin that label on Bush are not merely misguided, they are in total denial and delusional about reality.
One down; two to go.
UPDATE: Blogs for Bush has a nice update on the history of the North Korean problem.
Sunday, September 12, 2004
A Triumph of Democracy
For years, we've heard from both Right and Left that the "Big Media" are a problem. Each group thinks they are the handmaiden of the other group. What both appear to agree on is that they are near-all powerful entities who are growing unchecked like some electromagnetic cancer upon the land. The Left has long had the small alternative press, which tried to counter the power
of the Big Guys, but with limited success, and it had academia. The Right, since the 80s anyway, has had the think-tank world (which I've always viewed as the alternative university for libertarians and conservatives who perceived themselves, perhaps wrongly, as being closed out of academic by what they saw as leftist power). However it had no real media of its own (Jim and Tammy Faye don't count) until the advent of the Internet. There's a reason the earliest and
most well-known blogs lean conservative or libertarian: there was a latent demand for their services.The net finally reduced the cost of publishing to near zero, at least on the margin, and radically democratized the knowledge production industry, especially investigative reporting. By eliminating both political (think broadcast licenses) barriers to entry and the huge start up
costs of publishing, the Internet widened the sphere of liberty for those who wished to be producers of information. The result, as we've seen so clearly the last 48 hours, is that the strength of Big Media power has been radically reduced. Average Americans, with their knowledge of typewriters, military procedure, or fairly obscure terms like "kerning," were able to compete with, and effectively neutralize, one of the most powerful organizations on the
planet.
Some see this as nothing less than a new revolution in media. The distributed intelligence of the internet replacing Big Media; the common man's experience x 1 million replacing journalists, and that we will all be better off for it.
However, before the Triumph of the Net is made into a movie, I would like to propose that rather (a bad word, I know) than replacing the Print and TV News media; the internet will actually become a resource and tool for those media--at least for the media that are capable of changing their dinosaur mentalities. In the NEW MEDIA that would evolve from this union, there would be a far more objective and "fair and balanced" perspective that is missing from the Old Media--as represented by CBS. Editorial decisions, as well as research, fact-checking; analysis etc. could all be functions of the utilization of the Net by the Print and TV news. Those outlets that are flexible and appreciate the vast resource available for their stories; and are able to appreciate the speed as well as the varied perspectives available to them in developing a news story would be able to dominate this new market.
The mainstream media have been losing customers for some years now. I believe the reason why this is occurring can be traced directly to the conscious and unconscious biases of those who control and operate those media. While some outlets deliberately have a particular ideology and make all their news stories "fit" into that procrustean agenda; others are not even aware that they are bias because of the "cocoon" that the owners, editors and writers live in. Those of us can see it from the outside looking in; but they, long ago, lost the ability to see themselves as others see them. They truly believe that their opinions are the holy Truth and so are able to see only those news stories that fit their Truth. This latter scenario is probably the case with the CBS fiasco. I would like to think that the deception was not a deliberate attempt to foist their particular beliefs in the middle of a presidential election, but we shall see, won't we?
In this triumph of Democracy, Liberty and the Common Man (and Woman), we will see the beginnings of many changes in the world of News and Information Dissemination. It is like a tidal wave of freedom, and it bodes well for the entire world.
Not Another One!
Saturday, September 11, 2004
Defenders of Truth
A pop quiz.
Question: What do the following facts have in common?
-Juan Williams saying that it doesn't matter if the memos are faked, it only matters if the content is true (no link, but I watched it yesterday);
-Dan Rather continuing to insist that his story is "essentially correct" even if the overwhelming number of facts prove it wrong;
-Paul Krugman defending Fahrenheit 911 for its "essential truth" despite its lies and deceptions;
Answer:
Far from being the "Defenders of Truth" that I imagine these people see themselves as, what they all have in common is a complete disdain, and even contempt, for the concept of an objective, verifiable Truth. Unbeknownst to them, they represent Truth's greatest enemies. Why?
Because, what they all are promulgating is that Truth is elastic; Truth is relative; Truth is whatever you want it to be if it feels "right" to you. Facts and Reason be damned. Distortion and even lies are acceptable if you are pursuing a "greater" Truth.
Much greater thinkers than I am have grappled with this issue. Aristotle, Ayn Rand and Thomas Sowell come to mind. But let me just take on Mr. Williams, NPR Correspondent for a moment. Let's say I forged a memo that said:
September 11th, 1991
MEMO: CYA
1. Moody is putting pressure on the news staff to treat Williams’ opinions and hack jobs with respect and lay off asking the hard questions. I have said that he will drive viewers interested in truth away, but it’s clear he’s already gone to the top to get
approval. As his supervisor, I am not permitted to say anything negative and have to sugarcoat my evaluation of his performance.
2. It’s well known that Williams performance on the show has been extremely poor and that he is always whining about getting less exposure than other reporters. I will let him stay on the program, but respect is something I can’t give him.Chet Huntley
Senior Correspondent
Would you have to accept that the contents are "true", Mr. Williams? Mr. Huntley is deceased, so we can't ask him if he wrote it. Oh, was he already dead in 1991? He died in 1974 when you were just a kid? But that's irrelevant since the content of the memo has "essential truth"--at least from my perspective. So, I think we should focus on the content, not the possibility that it was forged! Why waste time on minor details? I feel your views are "stupid", and I believe you are a lousy reporter and news analyst-- so it shouldn't matter that I "faked" the memo, or forged Huntley's name to it, should it? It serves that greater truth.
"But it’s not true--and can't possibly be real!" you might say. But, Mr. Williams, IT IS MY TRUTH, isn't it? It's what I feel, deep in my heart; and since I have no objective evidence outside of my feelings (except of course for almost every word from your own mouth), I decided to take Truth into my own hands, do everyone a favor and write a memo that proves what a moron you are. I believe that by doing so I have become a true "Defender of Truth"like you claim to be. Some people might suggest that it makes me a lying, cheating, opportunistic sleazebag. But hey! They don't understand the real nature of Truth, like you and I do.
IF YOU HAVE ACTUAL FACTS, PRODUCE THEM. Reporters have been trying to prove for many years now that Bush was AWOL; that he didn't meet his obligation and that he was caught in a dereliction of duty. They think it is true because their feelingsabout Bush make it true.
But the TRUTH is that President Bush was HONORABLY DISCHARGED from the ANG. And that precludes the possibility that he was AWOL; in dereliction of his duty; or somehow "failed to meet his obligations." The TRUTH is that President Bush has shown himself to be an effective, decisive and even innovative Commander-in-Chief, and he doesn't even have to rely on his record of 35 years ago! He can run on his record of achievement of the last 4 years.
But, if it makes you feel any better, I can certainly understand why your method of confusing feeling with thinking is so popular. I feel really wonderful calling people like you, Dan Rather,Paul Krugman, and Michael Moore complete assholes!
But, you see, I don’t actually have to resort to feelings, lies, distortions, forgeries, emotional projection or intellectualization to prove my point; since I'm willing to let history decide. I think the facts are on my side.
UPDATE: I was commenting over at Roger Simon's blog and another commenter posted this, in reponse to my blogpost here:
Dr. Sanity
Thanks for the link. I've been enjoying your comments.
What keeps striking me about this are the two views of reality, of truth, espoused by Plato and Aristotle respectively. For Plato, the only "true" circle was the imaginary, perfect circle. All the real circles we see around us, which are always flawed, are only imperfect copies of the one true circle which exists in the one true reality. For Plato the ideas were paramount and the world of the senses was secondary.
For Aristotle, whose father was a Greek physician, in the long tradition of famous Greek physicians (cf. "I, Claudius"), reality was what you see before you. Ideas you had about reality were just that, ideas. For Aristotle, the world of the senses was paramount and the world of ideas was secondary.
Epistemology necessarily precedes politics.
If "Bushitler is evil" is the one true reality, it scarely matters what occurs in the world of the senses. Whether the memos were faked or not, whether they make any sense or not, none of this has the least bearing on the ultimate reality to be found in the heads of these people. I'm sure they've long hence forgotten why they came to believe "Bushitler is evil" in the first place.
How can anyone fail to see the guise of the religious fanatic in such an attitude?
Posted by: WichitaBoy This was such a good post, WichitaBoy, that I had to include it on my site! Thankyou
A Rather Mini Mental Status Exam
A grasp of the temporal is extremely important in evaluating the mental status of an individual. It is called “Orientation” and it reflects an assessment of whether the person: 1) knows who he is; 2) knows where he is; and 3) knows the date/time (e.g., PERSON, PLACE, and TIME). When the disorientation is “acute” (relatively recent onset) the diagnosis is DELERIUM; When the condition is chronic (lasting for a long time) it is called DEMENTIA. I
In evaluating Dan Rather:
PERSON - he thinks he is God and doesn’t have to answer to anyone (it is possible this is just delusional, but delusional people aren’t necessarily oriented either)
PLACE - we can’t be sure what planet he is actually from, and he doesn’t appear certain either. TIME/DATE - as Jeff points out, Mr. Rather is unable to tell the difference between Pacific Time and Central Time.
Since his condition has been chronic and seem to have been going on for years, the most likely diagnosis is DEMENTIA. Possibly more tests will be needed to distinguish that diagnosis from a delusional psychosis.
NEVER FORGET
The 2nd Tower is hit.... The numbers are indelible: 8:46 a.m. and 9:02 a.m. Time the burning towers stood: 56 minutes and 102 minutes. Time they took to fall: 12 seconds.
Go HERE for a slide show of pictures from the September 11th attacks.
NEVER FORGET THE ONES WHO DIED AND ARE NOW DYING TO PROTECT FREEDOM.
We must remember that this is a war we cannot afford to lose....and once again come together to pledge "our Lives, our Fortunes, and our Sacred Honor" to defeat the Islamofascist savagery that threatens our entire civilization.
Click here for a moving tribute "We Remember" from the Marines in Iraq
at American Daughter
Friday, September 10, 2004
40 Days....And Counting
"I have pledged that I am going to have a press conference at least once a month to talk to the nation about what I'm doing because I don't have anything to hide," Kerry said during a campaign stop in Beloit, Wis., after the Democratic National Convention. "I want America to know what I'm doing. I want you to know what I'm fighting for. I want you to ask me questions."
The Infinite Improbability Drive suggests that the odds of Kerry answering questions about HIS service in Vietnam and the SBVT accusations are 150,000 : 1 at the moment. But, I recommend you just grab your towels, don't panic, and hold on!

